Saturday, October 18, 2008

Do you believe?

We had our annual client "networking" event this past Thursday (no!! I promise this post is NOT going to be about work!!!).

We'd been planning it for months and one of the "attractions" of the evening was a show by Roberto Strizzi.

Since we wanted to make sure that this guy was not a fraud (and avoid a huge embarrassment in front of our clients) we went to see his show before hand last week and I have to say I came out not exactly sure of what IS and what ISN'T possible anymore.

Roberto is an "illusionist". Basically he can read minds and "connect" with people he has never met before. I never used to believe in this sort of stuff... (although for the record, I do believe in aliens, but that's a whole other story) but after Roberto's show I'm no longer that certain.

He begins his show by randomly selecting two audience members to come up on stage (I say randomly because they way they are selected is he throws a crunched ball of paper to an audience member and turns around while he makes us throw the ball of paper from one person to another across the room (kindda like playing hot potato) until he yells stop. The person with the ball is "it").

He then asks one of the two volunteers to put a coin on each of his (Roberto's) eyelids and then wrap his face with black duck tape. Once he's completely blindfolded he asks the other volunteer to collect a series of objects from the audience on a little tray. Again, this is all random stuff (one of my colleagues threw in her metro pass on the tray). Once the objects are collected he holds the hand of the person who passed the tray and asks her to select one by one the objects with her other hand so that in no way he physically touches them but is still connected to them through the volunteer. He than proceeds not only to describe precisely what the object is (color, material, shape..) but what it means to the owner. For instance, he guessed the metro pass of my colleague, but was even able to state that the metro pass belonged to "Martine" and that she's had it for 3 years and counting (this was confirmed by Martine herself!). Another amazing example was when the object in question was a small pretty funky tin case and not only did he guess what the object was, but he even surprised the owner by saying that the case had the logo of her small business of organic sandwiches and how she was a vegetarian. The owner was sitting right behind me and I literally heard her "gasp in amazement".

Ok, so I admit this first part still let me a bit skeptical (although he did ask the volunteers to stick a finger in each of his ears as proof that he wasn't wearing any ear prompters or stuff like that).

But then I had a chance to test first-hand his "mind reading skills".

He distributed to each of the audience members a sheet of paper with a number on one side and a blank spot on the other. He then asked us to write a question on the blank side and then to tear the sheet in half leaving the number on one piece of paper and the question on the other. After asking us to fold our "question piece" in four, he passed a pouch around to collect all of the questions and then dumped all the pieces on a table near by. He never once touched a single sheet. He then asked us to do the same (fold in four and dump into the pouch) the piece with our number on it after having us memorize our number.

He then proceeded to randomly select 5 numbers out of the pouch and asked the audience members who's number was called out to come up on stage. I kept hopping that he call out my number because a) I had cheated on my question and b) I wanted to test first hand his "powers".

And what do you know? HE CALLED OUT MY NUMBER!!!

So up on stage I went with four other audience members. One by one, he took us by the hand and proceeded to talk about our "question". The first two girls before me it seems where amazed when he pretty much "guessed what their question was about" sometimes even coming up with the name of a guy or a place that was directly related to their question. Then came my turn.

Don't laugh, but my very first thought was "shit! I hope he doesn't read my mind too much 'cuz I haven't shaved my legs in ages and it's a pretty gross sight"...

He took my hand and looked at me and went "hmmmmm.....your case is a particular one. I bet you are translating the word "zut" in your heard right now, right?" ("zut" means "uh-oh" in french btw). He looked at me a little longer and said "your question is not a simple yes or no answer, is it? it has something to do with you and another person, right?". I nodded and internally thought "this guy's a fraud, that's way too easy".... he then surprised me by saying "This is not professional, I'll have to get back to you a little later" and led me back to my seat...............




..........................................................





.........................................................................................





(WTF!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)



However, the more I think about it the more unsettled I become. Here's why:

a) First of all, I say I cheated on my question because I wrote it in english. I can't help asking myself if that's why he asked me if I was translating the word zut in my head.

b) My question was simply this: "will the answer be yes?". I can't really talk about the actual context of the question yet, but I will say this: it has to do with hubby's and my careers......

c) Sitting in the audience was one of my bosses. I can't help thinking that Roberto sensed this and thought it was perhaps not a good idea (read: professional?) to "answer my question" in front of my boss which, it's reasonable to say, is right.

d) However, I had written my question as ambiguously as possible precisely because my boss was in the audience but then again, is that why Robert had said my question was not "a simple yes or no" matter? .....

The rest of the show was more astonishing performances and intriguing precise guessing games. I have to say that the show he put on for our clients was just as mind boggling and several of our guests later came up to tell us how impressed they had been by Roberto's show.

So what do you say? Do you believe in this stuff?
If so, do you think he knew about my unshaved legs? gulp!!

Fned.

P.S. For those of you living in Paris, I totally recommend his show (every Monday evening at the Thêatre Clavel (19th district) -- 3 euro fee).

8 comments:

JJ said...

I believe in that kind of stuff, our Mexico Way has a gift, you know. But there are certainly a lot of frauds out there so I can understand your skepticism. The real question is... did he answer your question?

Anonymous said...

Illusionists freak me out, totally. One guy came into the bar I worked in, told me to just think of a card, any card. So in my mind, I thought of the Jack of Spades. He pulled out a deck of cards, which had little stick figures drawn in the top corner. He proceeded to flip the cards fast, so it looked like the little stick guy was moving...and by the last card, the little stick figure drawing was holding in his hand a tiny Jack of Spades.

I was so freaked out I made him leave my bar.

Bluestreak said...

I'm very cynical when it comes to this kind of stuff (mind reading, tarot cards, etc). I don't know, I just don't buy it. People always go and say they got a "bad reading" or a "good reading". I say it's because the person is guessing and if they guess even close, it's a good reading.

Jonnifer said...

There's GOT to be a reason, hasn't there? Aren't there books explaining how they do it? Ahh, I have to see this for myself, it's too weird! Good job on testing him with your English question, btw. Make him work for it.

Fned said...

JJ: OMG, if Mexico Way can read minds, we're ALL in trouble (LOL). I didn't exactly answer my question, but he did say just enough to have me doubt... which I guess is the idea.

Heather in Paradise: dude, that is freakish!!! But then again, I'm skeptical of all "magic tricks" that involve playing cards ever since I learned that there are certain decks that come with markings on the back that help you "cheat". Still.... I would have definitely kicked him out of my bar too...

Bluestreak: That's what I thought too at the beginning: that a lot of it has to do with reading correctly the "body language signs". Like for instance, if you ask a question and see the person in front of you squirm nervously then you know that you're on the right track, or if on the contrary he makes a puzzled face then you know you're getting cold... stuff like that... but that still doesn't explain all of it.... ;s

Jonnifer: I have to admit I've never checked to see if there are books explaining how they do it. Definitely go see his show if you and Phil can. Then let me know what you think!!! :D

minshap said...

I believe that we are all gifted with ESP in some form, but most of us don't know how to tap into it. This guy sounds like he does and if he ever comes here, I will see his show. You did a great job bamboozling him fned - and then again, was he really bamboozled? I think not! You should write him a letter and ask him for the answer since he didn't want to give it to you in front of your boss.

Animesh said...

While I _do_ believe that there are things we do not know about mind-power [and astrology - but that's another discussion], I also believe that a majority of people are simple hoaxters that depend on _you_ to feel that they have cracked it. Seriously, if he has the power to see random objects held in people's hands, he definitely also has the power to read what is on a piece of paper, so no point in NOT answering your question directly.

Watch "the mentalist" sometime. Is a cool TV series about a guy with similar "powers".

And next time we meet, I shall read your palm and tell you your fate ;).

Anonymous said...

The guy is not a hoaxter, he does not claim any special powers and leaves you to guess how its done. The one "trick" you dont mention is him stopping his heart for a few seconds. Cheating does not seem possible on that one.(The "supervising" nurse was friend of mine who takes no nonsense; his pulse disappeared from his wrist.)
For the rest, tricks are possible: An object he guessed while not seeing was a coin wallet, but not how much money was in it.(He could not "see" what the audience/a helper could not see. There always seems to be a direct relation between what he says and what was written on the paper("Yes")
Personnaly I think the magic is in the words/the showmanship.
Anyway an excellent show, highly recommended!

Share2